Intrinsic excitement apart, these are not only deeply moving accounts but quite poignant - like an ambitious beginner, Rubinstein?s concept exceeds his grasp, yet unlike an artist embarking upon a lifetime voyage of skills catching up to inspiration. This is why, despite the U. The tree had lots of dead leaves on it. So, rather than being an anomaly it turns out that this is as close to an authentic interpretation as any we have. The Franck is conceived along similar lines and provides a nice complement.